dytch tools - free
Is that direct shipper load worth it?
Enter the numbers from your brokered setup, then your own assumptions for running the lane direct. You get the direct rate per mile you would need to match what your brokered setup leaves you after the costs you list. Sometimes that number is lower than you expect. Sometimes it tells you the broker is earning their cut.
Runs in your browser. Nothing you type goes anywhere. Every direct-side number is your assumption, not a promise about the market.

Your break-even direct rate
$0.00
Brokered week
Direct week at break-even
Test the margin, not just the rate
What if the lane takes more work?
Try extra deadhead or sales time before you quote. Each option uses your costs and leaves your original calculation untouched.
Interactive scenarios rendered with A2UI 1.0. Rule-based math, not an AI forecast. Runs only in your browser.
The assumptions behind this answer
Read this before you quote a shipper. This compares what each setup leaves after the costs you listed, nothing more. It cannot see a shipper's credit risk, whether they will actually give you the lane every week, contract terms, insurance differences, or what happens when a direct relationship goes quiet. A broker also buys you load volume and someone else doing the selling. Use the break-even as your floor in a rate conversation, not as proof that direct always wins. Some weeks it will, some weeks it will not, and the honest answer depends on inputs only you know. If you left the cost-per-mile field blank, both nets are before truck costs; the comparison still works, but neither number is money in your pocket.
Found a lane that beats the number? Read how to find direct shippers to haul freight for, or use the shipper type finder to see which shippers fit your equipment.
The math, before you type
How do you compare a brokered load with direct shipper freight?
Compare what each option leaves after the same categories of cost, not just the rate per loaded mile. This calculator finds the direct rate needed to match the brokered week's net after the costs you enter. It is a negotiation floor under your assumptions, not a market-rate forecast.
The break-even formula
Brokered net = brokered rate × loaded miles × (1 − brokered payment-fee share) − operating cost per mile × (loaded + empty miles).
Direct break-even rate = [brokered net + direct truck costs + direct sales/admin time cost] ÷ [direct loaded miles × (1 − direct payment-fee share)].
Direct payment fees combine the factoring and invoicing/collections percentages you enter. Sales/admin time cost is hours × hourly value: opportunity cost, not a cash invoice. The operating cost applies to all miles on both sides. A 3% fee is 0.03 in the formula.
A worked example, not an industry average
Suppose a brokered week pays $2.50 per loaded mile for 2,000 loaded and 200 empty miles. At 3% payment fees and $1.50 operating cost per mile, that leaves $1,550 after those costs: $5,000 gross − $150 in fees − $3,300 in truck costs.
Now suppose direct freight still gives you 2,000 loaded miles, but 300 empty miles, 4% combined payment fees, and five hours of sales/admin work valued at $30 per hour. The direct rate needed to match that $1,550 is ($1,550 + $3,450 + $150) ÷ (2,000 × 0.96), or approximately $2.68 per loaded mile ($2.6823 before rounding).
These are invented example inputs to explain the calculation, not observed carrier results or current freight rates. Change the empty miles, fees, utilization or time and the answer changes.
What does the calculation leave out?
It cannot verify shipper credit, payment reliability, repeat volume, contract terms, insurance differences, detention or the cost of replacing a lane that disappears. Add relevant costs to your own review before quoting. Leaving operating cost blank means the displayed nets are before truck costs, not take-home profit.
Learn how to find direct shippers → · Find shipper types for your equipment → · See dytch's shipper research and outreach service →
Your next step
A better front door.
A clearer next step.
Tell us about your company, your current website and how driver inquiries reach your team. We can start with the part that needs work.
Talk about your project ↗Next step
Winning more direct shipper work starts with a site they can check. Website design for trucking companies ↗